Here are my overall thoughts (a lot of this is reductive or flippant, so be warned):
Yale pro: everything except con: New Haven
Stanford pro: weather, environment, prestige con: Palo Alto kinda boring
Harvard pro: prestige, Boston con: winter winter winter
Columbia pro: New York, quality con: not good neighborhood
NYU pro: NY, neighborhood con: not as much prestige
Chicago pro: prestige, clerkships con: cold, neighborhood
Michigan pro: college town, quality con: you're in Michigan
Virginia pro: quality, COL con: you're in small-town VA
Penn pro: quality con: not a big fan of PA
Duke pro: quality, COL con: Durham
Northwestern pro: quality con: no WE
Cornell pro: New York con: Ithaca
Boalt pro: prestige, Bay area con: GPA whore
Georgetown pro: DC con: bigger class size = harder placement