Definitely Pitt. The Pittsburgh legal market is full of Pitt lawyers. It's far and away the top school in the market. A little extra debt is okay when you look at the extra options it affords you. Like someone above said, if it was a full ride from Duquesne it'd be a little different, but Pitt's public school tuition is reasonably cheap even out of state anyway. Plus, unless you're already from a rust belt city like Pittsburgh, Cleveland, Buffalo, Cincinnati, etc., be prepared for a pleasant surprise as you realize just how low the cost of living is.