Without factoring in money, for New York it's Emory > Tulane > Mason. There's a significant gap each time.
I'd heard varying things- some saying Tulane has better NYC placement and some saying Emory. I'd reccomend wait and see if Fordham accepts you on the second evaluation. And the money from SHU is nothing to sneeze at either.
Pay close attention to the students who attend the event for each law school-- while not all of them will end up there, these could be your fellow 1Ls and future colleagues. Can you see yourself working alongside them for the next 3 years, too?
Where does everyone go to find out who recruits at OCI? I can't seem to find it on NALP, and not all schools publish that info.