Is there any contest? I picked GW and Vandy. You have good numbers for both of them, why go lower?
This is a difficult situation. You say that you are not interested in biglaw, not interested in prestige, you've chosen primarily schools around the New York area in the past, but now ask a bunch of mostly-anonymous peopleto selct the best Southern/Midwestern schools for you without giving them any indication of what you do[/u] want from your degree. It'd be easier to vote if you told us what factors actually matter to you.
I vote NYU, because that's where the cool kids go.