Total Members Voted: 89
QuoteFalse dichotomy.False dichotomy depends upon the laws of non-contradiction, excluded middle and identity. Your first clue that this is so is that a false dichotomy is a logical fallacy.
Alright.I say classical logic is absolutely valid. Do you agree or disagree?There's no need to tell me why you agree or disagree. Just tell me whether you agree or disagree.
There's an invisible teacup out beyond the orbit of Mars. No instrument will ever detect it, but it's there, damn you!
If I say either A or B is true and you say "false dichotomy!", you are saying it is not the case that either A or B is true, which is to say your objection relies upon the validity of classical logic.
QuoteThere's an invisible teacup out beyond the orbit of Mars. No instrument will ever detect it, but it's there, damn you!Unlike the statement "classical logic is absolutely valid", this statement above may be denied.
I can say that classical logic is not absolutely valid.
Page created in 0.352 seconds with 21 queries.