Seems like you have a tough choice ahead of you. Cinci is a good school. I have a friend who is attending (1L) and loves it. Plus, it really isn't that far from Columbus. This begs the question, however, do you plan to continue to work while attending law school, or do you just want to stay in Columbus?
From what I understand, Capital has both an evening and part time program for those who work there way through school. Further, if they are offering almost all expenses, it would be hard for anyone to pass up.
The good thing is you still have some time to decide, and a few other law schools to hear from.
Overall, however, I agree with Valerie. Depending on what type of law you want to practice, the "Tier" won't matter 10 years from now.