Yes, I think they are trying to act like they are Emory or UGA when they are not!
I had a good GPA, a good LSAT score, strong Extracurricular involvement in college, i.e. editor of the university newspaper, president of ODK, etc. and after college I've been involved in community and professional organizations, I'm good looking...just kidding! But, I was surprised that I got waitlisted there and am being treated rather shabbily by the Admissions Department.
So, unless I get off of the William and Mary or Georgia State waitlist, I'll be relocating, at the last minute, to Birmingham and leaving my wife behind in Atlanta. My wife is a career woman through and through and I love it, but this is one time that it would be nice if she had no job and could just move wherever and whenever I went to law school. Because as it is she might stay in Atlanta until next year.