Financials are not that huge of a concern either. For example, I'm not strongly considering going to University of the Pacific to save the money.
Okay, if you actually donít care about location, then all I did was a quick comparison of bar, employment and cost numbers and these stood out:
1-Colorado (#38) - Exceptional numbers for Bar passage, passage vs state average, employment and cost. Offers lots of aid.
2-Washington and Lee (#34) - Better bar passage and passage vs state avg than W&M. Offers more aid.
3-William and Mary (#28) - Lower cost and higher US News rank than W&L.
Close Runner up - Ohio (#34) - Great bar passage and employment numbers, higher on the cost end. Offers highest percentage of aid on list.
I know you only got scholarship offers from those 2 you mentioned, but some people have had success negotiating for money. It might not hurt to ask politely and mention the steep discounts other schools gave you (no need to mention the rankings).
Hopefully this jogs some thoughts for you, good luck!