I'd be a bit concerned about your info re UoR compared to UVA - everywhere I've been (DC's about the closest to you), UVA is highly respected and UoR is pretty unheard of. However, local schools do often do well in their immediate surroundings and it wouldn't surprise me if UoR is good for working in R. If you ever decide to leave R, you'd be far better off with UVA on your resume. Also, I would be confident that you'd get a better education at UVA and your classmates will, on average, be of higher caliber.
You might also consider GMU as a middle-ground, particularly if UVA doesn't work out.
I don't know anything specific about Atty/CPA's and their job market, though the job market in general for lawyers is pretty poor.
There's certainly a lot to be said for graduating with zero debt vs $100k of debt (or whatever UVA will work out to be) and that should probably weigh pretty heavily.