Yea, you need to fix this. Disclose, its not a big deal. I had 2 DUI’s, but like you there is no record at all of my first one anywhere. So I wrote this on my bar app “I believe that in XXXX in the state of XX I got a DUI. I say I believe because there is no record of it anywhere that I could find. Likewise, my memory is a little fuzzy as I was, well, you know, drunk at the time it happened and it’s been 15 years ago but I’m pretty sure I got and plead guilty to a DUI…But my second DUI I remember that one well…..”
So far no issues with the bar, and there were no issues with my school either. BUT we had a guy come to our school and help us fill out the bar app and he said disclose EVERYTHING. He said they are not that concerned with what you did really, but they get very, very pissed off if you don’t disclose something, even trivial. Seems he was right because the bar has had my app since May 1st and not a word about it, but I know other classmates who got letters and had to explain stuff in a notarized letter, stupid stuff like why they never changed their DL to the state of the school.
I even disclosed a public intox and minor in passion that got DISMISSED just because I did not want them to find anything I did not already tell them about. Cover your ass now, so its not in the frying pan later.The bar has access to everytthing, expundged or not, and your finger prints which they run through a data base. They will find it. Disclosing is NOT as big a deal as you think it is, just do it.