Law School Discussion

Nine Years of Discussion
;

Poll

Should body fat percentage influence an employee's insurance premium?

No, group plans should charge all employees the same premium.
 13 (36.1%)
No, but other things like smoking and drug use should.
 4 (11.1%)
Yes, the fatter you get, the more you should pay.
 16 (44.4%)
Yes, fat people should have to pay less.  They need the money for food.
 3 (8.3%)

Total Members Voted: 36

Author Topic: Should Fat People Pay More?  (Read 5016 times)

jack24

  • Sr. Citizen
  • ****
  • Posts: 1050
    • View Profile
Should Fat People Pay More?
« on: March 23, 2009, 12:36:05 PM »
In many (maybe most) states, non-government group insurance plans can not use physical fitness, body fat, lifestyle, or genetic history as determining factors for insurance premiums.  Is that a good thing?  Is there a privacy concern? Would higher rates for fat people just discourage them from having any coverage at all?
Discuss.

Matthies

  • LSD Obsessed
  • *****
  • Posts: 5988
    • View Profile
    • Tell me where you are going to school and you get a cat!
Re: Should Fat People Pay More?
« Reply #1 on: March 23, 2009, 12:49:03 PM »
What about higher rates for people who play sports or engage in athletic activities. Every time Iím skiing I see someone coming down out of the park on a ski patrol meat wagon likely because they screwed up a 20 foot jump trying to land fakie or something.

Iím thinking my premium is paying for that kid, or the guy who does not wear a helmet, or the guy who rides his bike in the street or people who play in the company softball league, or the guys playing b-ball at the school, or the guy who gets on a ladder to empty his gutters, or the person who likes to tan and gets skin cancer.

I think once you start saying peopleís actions should be covered or not covered based on what they do/donít do you can find a reason to deny claims to everyone: if you active no claims your too risky, if you sedentary no claims you should get out and be active.  ::)
*In clinical studies, Matthies was well tolerated, but women who are pregnant, nursing or might become pregnant should not take or handle Matthies due to a rare, but serious side effect called him having to make child support payments.

jack24

  • Sr. Citizen
  • ****
  • Posts: 1050
    • View Profile
Re: Should Fat People Pay More?
« Reply #2 on: March 23, 2009, 12:56:52 PM »
What about higher rates for people who play sports or engage in athletic activities. Every time Iím skiing I see someone coming down out of the park on a ski patrol meat wagon likely because they screwed up a 20 foot jump trying to land fakie or something.

Iím thinking my premium is paying for that kid, or the guy who does not wear a helmet, or the guy who rides his bike in the street or people who play in the company softball league, or the guys playing b-ball at the school, or the guy who gets on a ladder to empty his gutters, or the person who likes to tan and gets skin cancer.

I think once you start saying peopleís actions should be covered or not covered based on what they do/donít do you can find a reason to deny claims to everyone: if you active no claims your too risky, if you sedentary no claims you should get out and be active.  ::)


Good point, but body fat is far easier to measure than the level of dangerous activities in a person's life.  The test would also be consistent and almost completely objective.  Skiing/snowboarding, for example, would be almost impossible to measure. How often do you go? How challenging are the resorts/runs you spend your time on? Do you wear a helmet? How safe is your equipment?  Do you ever do inverted tricks?   
Body fat is more consistent.  And body fat can be easily re-measured.  

This is wrong.

  • Sr. Citizen
  • ****
  • Posts: 1453
  • Dear LawDog3...
    • View Profile
Re: Should Fat People Pay More?
« Reply #3 on: March 23, 2009, 12:57:38 PM »
... or the guys playing b-ball at the school ...


How about the couple of guys who were up to no good?
I do not like hats.
I do not like them on bats.
I would not like them near cats.
I would not like them made out of mats.

'blueskies

  • LSD Obsessed
  • *****
  • Posts: 6021
  • your changing skyline is twisting me up inside
    • View Profile
Re: Should Fat People Pay More?
« Reply #4 on: March 23, 2009, 12:58:41 PM »
Your premium is also based on perexisting conditions...heart disease, diabetes, high blood pressure,etc. I would imagine obese people do end up paying higher premiums
awkward follows you like a beer chasing a shot of tequila.

just some guy

  • Sr. Citizen
  • ****
  • Posts: 416
  • WARNING: May Contain Troll or Flame-like Substance
    • View Profile
Re: Should Fat People Pay More?
« Reply #5 on: March 23, 2009, 01:01:21 PM »
Isn't it enough that they pay more for sex?
I have courted the fire for a very long time, and many sparks have flown in the past, but [this post] speaks, finally, the language of the flame itself.
with apologies to Keith Jarret

jack24

  • Sr. Citizen
  • ****
  • Posts: 1050
    • View Profile
Re: Should Fat People Pay More?
« Reply #6 on: March 23, 2009, 01:01:47 PM »
Your premium is also based on perexisting conditions...heart disease, diabetes, high blood pressure,etc. I would imagine obese people do end up paying higher premiums

In my state, pre-existing conditions do not apply to group/employer health coverage.
There is a waiting period of 6 months, so sick people can't just get a job to pay for their medical bills.  (Unless they can tough it out for 6 months)

Matthies

  • LSD Obsessed
  • *****
  • Posts: 5988
    • View Profile
    • Tell me where you are going to school and you get a cat!
Re: Should Fat People Pay More?
« Reply #7 on: March 23, 2009, 01:21:47 PM »
What about higher rates for people who play sports or engage in athletic activities. Every time Iím skiing I see someone coming down out of the park on a ski patrol meat wagon likely because they screwed up a 20 foot jump trying to land fakie or something.

Iím thinking my premium is paying for that kid, or the guy who does not wear a helmet, or the guy who rides his bike in the street or people who play in the company softball league, or the guys playing b-ball at the school, or the guy who gets on a ladder to empty his gutters, or the person who likes to tan and gets skin cancer.

I think once you start saying peopleís actions should be covered or not covered based on what they do/donít do you can find a reason to deny claims to everyone: if you active no claims your too risky, if you sedentary no claims you should get out and be active.  ::)


Good point, but body fat is far easier to measure than the level of dangerous activities in a person's life.  The test would also be consistent and almost completely objective.  Skiing/snowboarding, for example, would be almost impossible to measure. How often do you go? How challenging are the resorts/runs you spend your time on? Do you wear a helmet? How safe is your equipment?  Do you ever do inverted tricks?   
Body fat is more consistent.  And body fat can be easily re-measured.  

When are you going to check body fat, every six months, people get fat/skinny all the time. What if the fat guy has not health problems but the skinny guy has a history of heart desease in his family, he should pay less?Why not just deny anyone who gest injured on the slopes on the basketball court, gets ahead injury w/o helemt, drive a car w/o air bags, drinks caffinee, goes to law school and gets stressed. Its never ending, best way is let the system price out general risk in population, bigger probklem is people w/o insurance at all.
*In clinical studies, Matthies was well tolerated, but women who are pregnant, nursing or might become pregnant should not take or handle Matthies due to a rare, but serious side effect called him having to make child support payments.

This is wrong.

  • Sr. Citizen
  • ****
  • Posts: 1453
  • Dear LawDog3...
    • View Profile
Re: Should Fat People Pay More?
« Reply #8 on: March 23, 2009, 01:29:07 PM »
What about higher rates for people who play sports or engage in athletic activities. Every time Iím skiing I see someone coming down out of the park on a ski patrol meat wagon likely because they screwed up a 20 foot jump trying to land fakie or something.

Iím thinking my premium is paying for that kid, or the guy who does not wear a helmet, or the guy who rides his bike in the street or people who play in the company softball league, or the guys playing b-ball at the school, or the guy who gets on a ladder to empty his gutters, or the person who likes to tan and gets skin cancer.

I think once you start saying peopleís actions should be covered or not covered based on what they do/donít do you can find a reason to deny claims to everyone: if you active no claims your too risky, if you sedentary no claims you should get out and be active.  ::)


Good point, but body fat is far easier to measure than the level of dangerous activities in a person's life.  The test would also be consistent and almost completely objective.  Skiing/snowboarding, for example, would be almost impossible to measure. How often do you go? How challenging are the resorts/runs you spend your time on? Do you wear a helmet? How safe is your equipment?  Do you ever do inverted tricks?   
Body fat is more consistent.  And body fat can be easily re-measured.  

When are you going to check body fat, every six months, people get fat/skinny all the time. What if the fat guy has not health problems but the skinny guy has a history of heart desease in his family, he should pay less?Why not just deny anyone who gest injured on the slopes on the basketball court, gets ahead injury w/o helemt, drive a car w/o air bags, drinks caffinee, goes to law school and gets stressed. Its never ending, best way is let the system price out general risk in population, bigger probklem is people w/o insurance at all.

I would vote Matthies into office any day.  Sound fiscal and social decision making AND kinky porn recommendations.  Does it GET any better?
I do not like hats.
I do not like them on bats.
I would not like them near cats.
I would not like them made out of mats.

iahurricane

  • Sr. Citizen
  • ****
  • Posts: 163
    • View Profile
Re: Should Fat People Pay More?
« Reply #9 on: March 23, 2009, 04:34:15 PM »
If people with lower body fat get discounts, I'm all for it.