I would say that the question is a little too broad to generalize on. While I do think that there is something to be said for being closer to clerkships, internships, and bar functions (a la Matthies advice on finding a job), if you can't stand living in the city why torture yourself with one more worry through law school? I think that all other things being similar though (same location, exit stats, scholarship money) being in a city could have a few advantages.