Law School Discussion

Lying about being a URM?

Say Yes

  • **
  • 11
  • Won't you come see me, Queen Jane?
    • View Profile
Lying about being a URM?
« on: August 12, 2008, 02:01:52 PM »
no need to do so because I am a URM, but saw this on the URM board and was very curious.has anyone here sat for a character and fitness exam?  if it truly is self identification, then the bar has no way to say you lied right?  i read over on TLS that only somehting like .002% of applicants are denied.  one anecdote says that a former cop who covered up a murder was denied, but also encouraged to re-apply in a few years.  surely self-identifying with a race that might not be your nationality isn't going to keep you from being admitted to the bar?

surely a law school could never know since it is self-identification?

Re: Lying about being a URM?
« Reply #1 on: August 12, 2008, 02:09:21 PM »
You might be able to pass the bar but might run into problems long before that in the form of the law school's equivalent of the character and fitness board. They might not care at all since it boosts their numbers whether or not you're actually a minority but god help you if they decide to launch a formal inquiry since they take lying pretty seriously.

America's Next Top Lawyer

  • ****
  • 420
  • Free at last!
    • View Profile
Re: Lying about being a URM?
« Reply #2 on: August 12, 2008, 04:00:08 PM »
no need to do so because I am a URM, but saw this on the URM board and was very curious.has anyone here sat for a character and fitness exam?  if it truly is self identification, then the bar has no way to say you lied right?  i read over on TLS that only somehting like .002% of applicants are denied.  one anecdote says that a former cop who covered up a murder was denied, but also encouraged to re-apply in a few years.  surely self-identifying with a race that might not be your nationality isn't going to keep you from being admitted to the bar?

surely a law school could never know since it is self-identification?

Somebody on this board tried it and got caught. I wouldn't try it.

remember, when you start classes they will ask you for a picture....

Re: Lying about being a URM?
« Reply #3 on: August 12, 2008, 04:31:56 PM »
Even if they ask you for a picture or see you, they cannot prove you are not a certain ethnicity (well, they could but they're not administering a DNA test).

The main problem is if Bar C & F or the law school looks at college applications and notices the discrepancy.  I still doubt one would get in serious trouble for this.

Realistically, no one will probably find out or care much.  Seriously though, who wants to be this sleazy?

PS-I don't think being a URM makes that much difference in the process.  It will only help if you are absolutely borderline and competing with a non-URM for the same spot.

meggo

  • ****
  • 581
    • View Profile
Re: Lying about being a URM?
« Reply #4 on: August 12, 2008, 10:36:29 PM »
I agree. And yes, many Hispanics look white (I myself have Spanish ancestry and look deathly pale) I would say that well above the majority of Chicano's and other Hispanics speak Spanish and have strong cultural ties to their ancestry. The hispanic side of my family speak Spanish and our ties go back well over 100 years. So I don't think that's a good example.   It doesn't take away that it's a shady thing to do and exploiting a system that was put in place to provide a bump for people who have been economically and socially disadvantaged (which despite people's occasional racist rantings on here, does exist).  You could theoretically lie on every bit of your application, convey a false story in your PS, discuss your diverse childhood growing up in a small village in the Andes, but lies are hard to maintain....