Do you really have no other options than these two? I'd say Creighton, too, but I'm wondering how the heck you ended up in this situation.
Thank you very much RonSanto. That was a very helpful post. For my situation, taking a shot at Villanova makes sense. I want to leave the door open for BigLaw, and I want to live in a major metro.
I also am not sure if you have visited Creighton (it sounded like you have visited Nova), but I can tell you from experience that the two are night and day in terms of people, COL, etc., so you might want to visit Creighton too if you decide you are serious about accepting their offer.