The difference in starting salary would likely be made up in the differences in cost of living. Choose based on where you want to live and work, as outside of the T30, your decision is mostly regional...where you want to live/work/etc.
Do you want to live in NYC? Go to Cardozo. Would you like a house, pool, and a white picket fence? Ohio is more likely to offer you and your future family those things. Would you prefer spending $500,000 on a large house in Ohio, or a 1 bedroom apartment in NYC?