I'm not sure how contrarian this answer is, but I say go to Fordham. If you want to be in NY/work there, you'll seee some very solid opportunities coming out of there - probably OCI with all the good firms except watchell. Given its no T14, but its got a great rep in the region, you'll save 60k, and you'll (potentially) compete better against Fordham 1Ls than you will at some of the more cutthroat schools.
There is, of course, the distinct possibility that i am completely wrong.