My UG rejection from Michigan was particularly obnoxious.
Something along the lines of "We don't feel you have the academic credentials to continue your education at the University of Michigan etc..."
I was like...um I have a 3.9 and a 1350 on the SAT...and you're telling me I'm not smart enough when you're probably accepting B or B- students from Michigan over me. Who the #(%$@# do you think you are?
I don't think you are right about that.
The joke around here (Michigan) is that it is impossible to get into U of M if your a Midwestern, white male.
I don't know either way, but that seems to be the feeling shared by that large majority of applicants.
What I can tell you, is that I know of plenty of 99% percentile ACT/SAT applicants with 3.75+ GPAs that have gotten rejected from U of M. Once again, couldn't tell you why. It is a very competitive school.