Do what works for you and don't worry about everyone else. Simple advice but if you take it to heart you will make your life much easier.
I want to learn legal writing. His feedback on into assignment number 2 for the final memo. I used the same language and analysis that he had approved and written "good job!" on-- and it was ripped to shreds in the final paper. I am not disputing constructive criticism or red ink-- those things make you a better writer. But I just don't understand why those issues weren't flagged in the earlier draft he critiqued. I plan to meet with him next week to discuss it, b/c I genuinely still don't understand where he is coming from, and I have him again for appellate advocacy next semester.Thoughts? I honestly just want my money back and to repeat the course with another professor... but that's not likely to happen.