Think like this: At which of those schools is my best shot to make top 10-15%? Bearing in mind that failing to do so at a T2 or T3 will leave you seriously hurting for a job. Also, don't even think about Pace. It's by all accounts a terrible school. NYLS probably has the better faculty of the three, but the competition there is stronger, bolstered by all the kids who are there on scholarship in lieu of Brooklyn or Cardozo. So not to be completely inconclusive - but as far brainscratchers go, this is a dilly of a pickle.