Let's see:
1. He's suggesting that we buy just about everything under the sun just to PREP for LS. I'm not made of money.
2. The book makes it seem like there is absolutely NO WAY to survive law school if you don't follow his advice, but his advice would have me prepping like 24/7 and I don't have that kind of time. I have a job.
3. His view of the classroom experience is less than comforting.
4. What? I'm supposed to do all my assignments and read the 9,000 books he's suggesting and still have time to eat or take a piss? I don't think so.
THAT is what's freaking me out.
1. I bought all of the core subject primers he suggests and the Delaney books for under $200 by using the Amazon marketplace or Half.com. I've seen the LEEWS system on ebay for pretty cheap...$60? I'm by no means made of money either.
2. If you follow the 13 week schedule (which gives you more than enough time to finish before school starts), you'll see you're not doing that much work per week.
3. Perhaps his visualization of the law school classroom experience is worst-case scenario, but wouldn't you rather prepare for the worst and be pleasantly surprised if you're wrong? His point is that the profs don't teach you black letter law by lecturing about it to you and telling you what you need to know as profs did about your typical subject matter in college. You have to do a lot of the work on your own. I prefer his "know your enemy" tactic myself.
4. Having done the prep over the summer, you are in a better position once classes start, as you are already familiar with the main ideas. You know what to focus on for exams and you are probably less stressed than everyone else who hasn't a clue what might lay ahead of them.
I was freaked out when I started to read the book too, but I appreciated the brutal honesty. I wanted to know what to expect, and I got a very clear picture. I hope it's not as bad as the author insists it is, and I would like to think that I'm a "natural born genius of the law", but the odds aren't in my favor, so I'm choosing to go with the PLS approach. Don't let it scare you!