21
Where should I go next fall? / Re: Advice on school reputation VS money offers! where would YOU go?!?
« on: March 18, 2005, 01:43:27 AM »
My brother is a respected attorney on the partner track at a prominent law firm in the area where I eventually want to practice and I asked him about rankings and tiers and how they effect employment opportunities. He knew how it worked at his firm but he called other lawyers around town to see how they saw the whole thing and gave me the general pecking order for hiring new attorneys.
Now this applies only to my neck of the woods (a mid-sized city in the deep South) and certainly does not represent how other markets operate but I think that it's a good illustration of how little rankings can matter in certain areas and how important it is to do research before passing up scholarship opportunities or paying thousands and thousands of dollars more to go to a slightly higher ranked school.
First in line are the guys with the family names regardless of the school they attended or their ability. Nepotism and the good ole boy system is alive and well in the south and it's hard to compete with guys from old families.
Next are the guys who have family members or friends that have pull in the legal community and can introduce them around town to other lawyers, vouch for them, and call in favors.
After that are the people with the best credentials (top of their class, Law review, etc) regardless of the national rank of their school.
Then come the guys that graduated from the dominant law school in the area- again regardless of how it ranks nationally.
Last is everyone else.
He also mentioned that some firms prefer to hire the boys from the area because firms invest a lot of resources in new attorneys and don't want them leaving town after a few years.
I see people on this board posting thing like "School A might jump from Tier 3 to Tier 2 and that will mean a HUGE increase in prestige and better job opportunities" or "School X is ranked 8 places higher than school Y so I would be stupid to go to attend a such a lower ranked school" when this may or may not matter in the market where they want to practice.
I'm not trying to start a debate or advocate anything. I just wanted to point out that it is important to evaluate your individual situation and the market where you want to practice and not rely completley on rankings and the conventional wisdom of this message board.
Now this applies only to my neck of the woods (a mid-sized city in the deep South) and certainly does not represent how other markets operate but I think that it's a good illustration of how little rankings can matter in certain areas and how important it is to do research before passing up scholarship opportunities or paying thousands and thousands of dollars more to go to a slightly higher ranked school.
First in line are the guys with the family names regardless of the school they attended or their ability. Nepotism and the good ole boy system is alive and well in the south and it's hard to compete with guys from old families.
Next are the guys who have family members or friends that have pull in the legal community and can introduce them around town to other lawyers, vouch for them, and call in favors.
After that are the people with the best credentials (top of their class, Law review, etc) regardless of the national rank of their school.
Then come the guys that graduated from the dominant law school in the area- again regardless of how it ranks nationally.
Last is everyone else.
He also mentioned that some firms prefer to hire the boys from the area because firms invest a lot of resources in new attorneys and don't want them leaving town after a few years.
I see people on this board posting thing like "School A might jump from Tier 3 to Tier 2 and that will mean a HUGE increase in prestige and better job opportunities" or "School X is ranked 8 places higher than school Y so I would be stupid to go to attend a such a lower ranked school" when this may or may not matter in the market where they want to practice.
I'm not trying to start a debate or advocate anything. I just wanted to point out that it is important to evaluate your individual situation and the market where you want to practice and not rely completley on rankings and the conventional wisdom of this message board.
Discussion
Resources