I think you should visit both schools and talk to students and the career office. Try to figure out which school is better for you and your career goals.
If the $$$ offer from UT is contigent on maintaining a certain GPA, I would think very carefully about it. Find out how many students hold on to their scholarships.
If your offer is contigent, and you really like Cinci more, I would go there over UT.
Good luck with your decision.
Thanks everyone for your comments. Yes, Toledo requires a 3.3 for the year to renew, which I'm told is likely 25-30% of the class. Cincinnati only requires a 2.0 to renew their scholarship.
Certainly, my goal will be top 20% at least. But, not acheiving that and losing the scholarship would be a double blow. Anyone have any information on the grading curve at UT?