If you are honestly looking at Yale, all that matters are GPA and an LSAT above 175. Even then you have no guarantees.
Why do people constantly post the same thing over and over again? Like it or not, Law School Admissions = LSAT + GPA. Sure, there are exceptions, but generally they are few and far between at any reputable school.
I was assuming the OP had good LSAT+GPA. As you point out in your (somewhat contradictory) post, LSAT+GPA are no guarantee of admission at Yale, even though they're a good start. I imagine extracurriculars are the next most important factor.