That doesn't sound like the makings of a great personal statement -- "At least I'm not in jail!" You don't really get bonus points for being a decent person and following the law. I think that maybe you just don't know what your unique story is. I seem to remember that Anna Ivey has a questionnaire that could help you figure out what your "story" is and write about that. The one you used for undergrad is probably not a good choice either.
Thanks for the reply. It not supposed to be an "at least im not in jail thing." It was more or less to show how I was able to make good decisions while those around me crapped on themselves and how it eventually lead me to decide to pursue a career in law.
Also, I googled Anna Ivey and found some stuff, but no questionnaire.